WASHINGTON — A jury on Monday convicted four members of the Oath Keepers of seditious conspiracy in the second batch of guilty verdicts related to the extremist group’s efforts to block the certification of the 2020 presidential election.
In addition to the seldom-used charge of seditious conspiracy, the four — Roberto Minuta, Joseph Hackett, David Moerschel and Edward Vallejo — were convicted of obstruction of an official proceeding and conspiring to obstruct.
U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta ordered the four to be placed under 24-hour house arrest with limited exceptions and limitations on internet usage until they are sentenced, “notwithstanding the nature of these charges, which are undoubtedly serious.”
Moerschel’s attorney, Scott Weinberg, told reporters that “we’re pretty disappointed with the verdict” and that they plan to appeal.
He said Moerschel and the other defendants were “swept up by the ‘Stop the Steal’ nonsense that was pushed by the president,” adding, “While people are responsible for their own actions, I think it’s important that all people take stock” and “take everything with a grain of salt, because when you follow somebody blindly, you end up in a terrible situation.”
The jury started deliberations Thursday morning after a five-week trial.
Prosecutors said the four used a “perverted version of American history” to justify their actions on Jan. 6, 2021.
“Attacking the Capitol was a means to an end,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Louis Manzo told jurors during closing arguments Wednesday. He said the group took advantage of the riot and seized the opportunity to fulfill their goal of preventing Congress from counting the electoral votes and confirming Joe Biden as the winner of the 2020 presidential election.
“January 6 was just a battle. The full conspiracy was to stop the transfer of power,” Manzo said.
Prosecutors said Vallejo was staged at a Virginia hotel with a stockpile of rifles — which they have called a “Quick Reaction Force” — while Hackett, Moerschel and Minuta led groups to breach the Capitol.
The trial, which started Dec. 12, included testimony from Brian Ulrich, a member of the Oath Keepers’ Georgia chapter who had pleaded guilty to seditious conspiracy and obstruction of an official proceeding. Ulrich testified that he took part in the storming of the Capitol because he wanted to stop the counting of the Electoral College votes.
“There’s no other reason to go in that building at that point,” Ulrich said.
Manzo also pointed jurors to clips from a selfie-style video of Minuta, recorded in what appears to be his car. In the video, a furious Minuta yells about fake ballots, complains that Congress hasn’t done enough about the problem and says children would become “slaves” if people don’t act.
“Millions will die,” Minuta said in another clip from the same video. “So what. So what. … I’m not afraid, and I’m ready to f—ing go.”
The four defendants were charged as part of the same seditious conspiracy case involving Oath Keepers founder Stewart Rhodes, which went to trial in October. The case was split into two trials because of the number of defendants.
Rhodes and Kelly Meggs, the leader of the group’s Florida chapter, were convicted of seditious conspiracy in November. Three additional defendants from the first trial — Jessica Watkins, Kenneth Harrelson and Thomas Caldwell — were acquitted of seditious conspiracy but convicted on other felony charges, including obstruction of a federal proceeding. All five are awaiting sentencing.
Weinberg said after Monday’s verdict that his client might have fared better had he been on trial with Rhodes. “I would have somebody to point to, to be like this is the real bad guy. So that’s why I think there was a discrepancy in the verdicts.”
Minuta’s lawyer, Bill Shipley, told reporters he didn’t think it was possible for the four defendants to get a fair trial from Washington jurors, whom he called “residents of a small judicial district who in one way or another were almost all impacted by the events of January 6th.”
A third seditious conspiracy trial involving members of the Proud Boys, another extremist group charged with trying to disrupt the peaceful transfer of power, is ongoing in Washington federal court.
The maximum sentence for seditious conspiracy — a rarely used Civil War-era statute — is 20 years in federal prison.
Lawyers for the defendants in the second trial said in their opening statements that their clients didn’t conspire to overthrow the government.
Defense attorney Angela Halim argued that Hackett, who she said had no military or law enforcement experience, was lumped into a “narrative” crafted by prosecutors about the Oath Keepers.
“There was no plan to attack the Capitol. There was no plan to disrupt the Electoral College proceeding,” she said of Hackett, who was seen on closed-circuit television video inside the Capitol on Jan. 6.
Weinberg took a similar tack. “This is not some highly organized group,” he said.
“These gentlemen had Twitter fingers, not trigger fingers,” Weinberg said, riffing on hip-hop artist Drake’s lyrics.
Vallejo, an Arizona resident, veteran and former Oath Keeper, came to Washington for Jan. 6 with “nothing but a servant’s heart,” his lawyer told jurors.
“Ed brought 30 days of food with him, not just for himself but for a group, and he believed he was going to a campground where he would set up a food kitchen and cook for protesters,” defense attorney Matthew Peed said in opening statements. “And it would be kind of a, kind of like a festival.”
He also stressed that Vallejo hadn’t met his co-defendants until the day of jury selection in the trial.
“There was literally zero coordination between these people,” Peed said.